Picked Most Often, Each Player
| Player |
Team(s) |
Picks |
| ARUBANS |
Giants |
 17 |
| CJOINT |
Dolphins |
 17 |
| GRANDMA |
Giants |
 17 |
| MIGHTY DUCK |
Rams |
 17 |
| MITCH |
Giants |
 17 |
| OMS |
Jets, Titans |
 17 |
| THEWINNER |
49ers |
 17 |
| YOGI |
Buccaneers |
 17 |
| CLUBBERS |
Cowboys |
 16 |
| LACABANA |
Eagles |
 16 |
| WORM |
Jaguars, Buccaneers |
 16 |
| DOC |
Bears |
 15 |
| LAREV |
Giants, Titans |
 15 |
| MICKTHEQUICK |
Bills, Eagles |
 15 |
| PAPA |
Saints, Eagles |
 15 |
| PEABODY |
Saints |
 15 |
| SWAMI |
Giants |
 15 |
| TBONE |
Bears |
 15 |
| WORKSUX |
Falcons |
 15 |
| AWAY |
Chargers, Patriots, Saints |
 14 |
| BUFFALO BOB |
Chargers |
 14 |
| CHIEF |
Lions |
 14 |
| MAD MAX |
Bills |
 14 |
| MARK |
Bills, Cowboys, Colts, Chargers, Jets |
 14 |
| PIP |
Chargers |
 14 |
| RAIDERNATION |
Lions, Chargers |
 14 |
| STEVY CHASE |
Buccaneers |
 14 |
| THE LAMA |
Cowboys, Lions |
 14 |
| WHEELS |
Steelers |
 14 |
| BRUTTA |
Lions |
 13 |
| HYFLYER |
Bears, Patriots, Buccaneers |
 13 |
| JOJO |
Eagles |
 13 |
| LARS |
Cowboys |
 13 |
| RMITCH |
49ers |
 13 |
| ROCKETMAN |
Chargers |
 13 |
| WARRIOR |
Eagles |
 13 |
| YOUNGMAN |
Cowboys |
 13 |
| JACOBI |
Lions |
 12 |
Picked Least Often, Each Player
| Player |
Team(s) |
Picks |
| LAREV |
Eagles |
0 |
| MIGHTY DUCK |
Raiders |
0 |
| CJOINT |
Cardinals |
 1 |
| HYFLYER |
Jets |
 1 |
| MARK |
Dolphins |
 1 |
| OMS |
Rams |
 1 |
| YOGI |
Titans |
 1 |
| AWAY |
Chiefs |
 2 |
| CLUBBERS |
Eagles |
 2 |
| GRANDMA |
Jaguars |
 2 |
| LARS |
Jets |
 2 |
| PEABODY |
Bills |
 2 |
| ARUBANS |
Chiefs |
 3 |
| JACOBI |
Ravens |
 3 |
| JOJO |
Cardinals, Falcons, Giants, Buccaneers |
 3 |
| LACABANA |
Browns |
 3 |
| MICKTHEQUICK |
Raiders, Jets |
 3 |
| RAIDERNATION |
Saints |
 3 |
| STEVY CHASE |
Bills |
 3 |
| SWAMI |
Patriots, Commanders |
 3 |
| TBONE |
Browns, Saints, Jets |
 3 |
| THE LAMA |
Texans |
 3 |
| BRUTTA |
Chiefs, Dolphins |
 4 |
| BUFFALO BOB |
Dolphins |
 4 |
| CHIEF |
Vikings, Giants |
 4 |
| MAD MAX |
Cardinals |
 4 |
| MITCH |
Texans, Jets |
 4 |
| PAPA |
Bills, Packers, Buccaneers, Commanders |
 4 |
| PIP |
Giants |
 4 |
| THEWINNER |
Saints, Jets |
 4 |
| WHEELS |
Jaguars |
 4 |
| WORKSUX |
Bears, Packers, Seahawks |
 4 |
| WORM |
Cardinals, Jets |
 4 |
| YOUNGMAN |
Vikings |
 4 |
| DOC |
Chiefs, Vikings, Commanders |
 5 |
| RMITCH |
Ravens, Raiders, Jets, Commanders |
 5 |
| ROCKETMAN |
Saints |
 5 |
| WARRIOR |
Patriots |
 5 |